Nonprofit vs. Not-for-Profit vs. For-Profit: 2026 Guide

If you’re an entrepreneur trying to figure out the best way to structure your new business, understanding the difference between the three common terms nonprofit, not-for-profit, and for-profit can be confusing. 

For example, people often use “nonprofit” and “not-for-profit” interchangeably, but each of these business structures is a distinct type with its own tax treatments, governance rules, and legal requirements. 

Understanding these differences matters because the business structure you choose affects everything from your tax obligations to how you can use your revenue. Here’s what you need to know to pick the right structure for your goals.

Ready to start your business? Create your website today or learn more about Shopify’s tools for selling online and in person.

What is a nonprofit?

A nonprofit exists to advance a social cause or provide a public benefit. Some common nonprofit missions focus on education, charity, research, animal welfare, and similar missions. Nonprofits can’t distribute profits to their owners or investors. Instead, every dollar generated goes directly back into funding the organization’s mission.

Running a nonprofit comes with significant tax advantages. You’ll typically receive exemptions from income tax, property tax, and often sales tax. The trade-off? Complete transparency about your spending and strict adherence to your stated mission.

Nonprofits take many forms, including colleges, research institutions, charities, and houses of worship. In the US, they’re commonly known as 501(c)(3) organizations, named after the tax code section that governs them. While nonprofits operate like businesses in many ways—raising funds, managing budgets, hiring staff—their bottom line serves the public good, not shareholders.

What is a not-for-profit?

A not-for-profit organization operates without generating profit for its owners. All revenue flows back into running the organization itself.

Here’s where not-for-profits differ from nonprofits: They don’t need to serve the public or advance a social cause. A not-for-profit can exist solely to serve its members’ goals or special interests. Your local recreational sports club? That can operate as a not-for-profit.

Not-for-profit organizations must still apply for tax-exempt status with the IRS, just like nonprofits. But there’s a crucial difference: Donations to not-for-profit organizations aren’t tax deductible for the donor.

What is a for-profit business?

A for-profit business has one primary objective: making money. This is true whether you’re in the business of selling products online, providing services, or developing solutions. Although many for-profit businesses also adopt their own mission statements, their goal, ultimately, is to generate profit. 

Unlike nonprofits and not-for-profits, for-profit businesses can distribute earnings to owners, shareholders, or investors as compensation for their investment and risk. Most ecommerce ventures fall into this category—opening an online store, selling wholesale, or selling on marketplaces.

For-profit businesses pay taxes on their earnings at federal, state, and sometimes local levels. Owners can take profits as personal income or reinvest them for growth—that flexibility is what attracts many entrepreneurs to this model.

The nonprofit sector in 2025: key statistics and trends

The nonprofit sector continues to grow and evolve, playing a crucial role in the US economy. As of 2023, there were two million nonprofit organizations in the United States, with 1.48 million holding 501(c)(3) tax-exempt status. This massive sector employed 12.8 million people in 2022, representing 9.9% of all private-sector jobs in the United States.

The financial impact is equally impressive. Total annual expenses for US nonprofits exceeded $2.46 trillion in 2022, showcasing the sector’s economic significance. Despite financial challenges, 61% of nonprofit leaders report that foundation revenue met or exceeded expectations in 2024.

Looking ahead, the sector shows resilience and growth potential. Seventy-seven percent of nonprofits report an increase in demand for their programs and services in 2025, while charitable donations are projected to increase by 4% in 2025. These trends suggest that whether you’re considering starting a nonprofit or partnering with one as a for-profit business, understanding this sector’s dynamics matters more than ever.

Nonprofit vs. not-for-profit vs. for-profit businesses

While nonprofits and not-for-profit organizations both qualify for tax-exempt status from the IRS, they differ significantly in scope and community impact. 

Let’s break down how all three structures compare:

Purpose and mission

Key differences

• Nonprofits dedicate themselves entirely to advancing social causes. They serve the public good and cannot distribute profits to owners or shareholders—every dollar stays within the mission.
• For-profit companies chase profitability for owners and shareholders. While they may serve communities or provide valuable services, generating returns remains the ultimate goal.
• Not-for-profit organizations occupy a middle ground. They can exist purely to serve their members’ or owners’ goals without advancing a social cause, but all profits must cycle back into operations.

Common ground

All three structures share one requirement: delivering value. Whether through services, products, or community support, each must provide something that adds value to peoples’ lives.

Liability protection

Key differences

• Nonprofit organizations can structure themselves as separate legal entities from their owners. This creates a structure similar to traditional corporations, but since profit isn’t the goal of nonprofits, they can’t technically be structured as a C corp. 
• Not-for-profit organizations typically function like general partnerships, without legal separation from members. However, some states like New York and Florida allow incorporation as separate entities while maintaining tax exemptions.
• For-profit businesses protect owners and shareholders from personal liability through structures like LLCs or corporations. When the business faces debt or legal issues, the organization bears responsibility. In those cases, individual owners are only responsible if they’ve personally guaranteed loans or engaged in illegal activities.

Common ground

Every business structure carries liability exposure. Legal troubles can make the organization responsible for debts or damages. However, proper structuring (like forming an LLC or corporation) typically shields personal assets from organizational debts.

Tax obligations

Key differences

• Nonprofits enjoy comprehensive tax exemptions. This includes no federal income taxes on revenue related to their charitable mission, plus potential exemptions from state income taxes, property taxes, and sales taxes, depending on location.
• Not-for-profits don’t distribute profits to owners but aren’t automatically tax exempt. Their tax obligations depend on their structure and activities, and they might still owe income taxes.
• For-profit businesses face full taxation on earnings: federal income taxes, state income taxes, and potentially sales or property taxes, based on business type and location.

Common ground

Tax obligations exist for everyone, while the specifics vary by structure and purpose. Both nonprofits and not-for-profit organizations can qualify for certain IRS tax exemptions.

501(c)(3) requirements and tax benefits

Key differences

To qualify as a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, organizations must meet strict IRS requirements. Your organization must be organized and operated exclusively for exempt purposes. This might include nonprofit organizations that fall under the following categories: religious, charitable, scientific, testing for public safety, literary, educational, fostering amateur sports competition, or preventing cruelty to children or animals. No part of your net earnings can benefit private shareholders or individuals.

The tax benefits for qualifying nonprofits are substantial. Beyond federal income tax exemption, donors can deduct contributions on their tax returns—a powerful fundraising incentive unavailable to not-for-profits. Nonprofits may also qualify for reduced postal rates, property tax exemptions, and sales tax exemptions in many states.

Not-for-profit organizations may qualify for different 501(c) subsections—like 501(c)(4) for social welfare organizations or 501(c)(7) for social clubs—but contributions to these organizations typically aren’t tax deductible for donors. 

For-profit businesses receive no special tax exemptions and cannot offer donors tax deductions for contributions.

Common ground

All organizations must file appropriate tax forms with the IRS. Even tax-exempt organizations must typically file annual information returns (Form 990 series) to maintain their status, though requirements vary by organization size and type.

Board governance and financial reporting

Key differences

When you run a nonprofit, you can expect to face strict governance requirements. Nonprofits must maintain a board of directors who serve without personal financial benefit, make decisions in the organization’s best interest, and ensure compliance with all legal requirements. Board members hold fiduciary responsibilities and can face personal liability for breaches of duty.

Financial transparency is also mandatory for nonprofits. They must file Form 990 annually with the IRS, making their financial information publicly available. This includes disclosing details about revenue sources, expenses, executive compensation, and program activities. Larger nonprofits often require or choose to have independent audits.

Not-for-profit organizations typically have less stringent governance requirements, though they still need proper management structures. Their financial reporting requirements depend on their specific tax-exempt category and state regulations. 

For-profit businesses have the most flexibility when it comes to board governance and financial reporting. They can structure their boards however they choose. Unless they’re publicly traded, for-profits can also keep their financial information private. 

Common ground

Regardless of which structure you choose to operate under, all organizations benefit from strong governance practices. Clear roles, regular meetings, documented decisions, and financial oversight help any organization operate effectively and avoid legal issues.

Revenue management

Key differences

• Nonprofits maximize revenues to support their causes. 
• Not-for-profit organizations don’t pursue revenue generation as a goal. Any money earned flows back into operations. For-profit businesses pursue revenue generation as their primary objective, distributing profits among owners and shareholders or reinvesting to support business growth.

Common ground

Revenue remains essential for survival across all structures. Each type of business needs income to cover expenses and continue operations, typically by offering something valuable to their target audiences.

Employment and compensation

Key differences

• Nonprofits often employ paid staff, including presidents or CEOs, though nonprofit workers’ salaries typically fall below for-profit levels, since resources focus on the public good. 
• Not-for-profit organizations frequently rely on volunteers, although not exclusively.
• For-profit businesses structure employment around profitability for owners and shareholders. They can offer competitive salaries, bonuses, and stock options to attract talent.

Common ground

People power every organization. The difference lies in compensation: Nonprofits and not-for-profits emphasize mission-driven work with potentially lower pay, while for-profits leverage financial flexibility to offer higher compensation.

Comparison table: nonprofit vs. not-for-profit vs. for-profit

This comprehensive comparison breaks down the key differences between nonprofit, not-for-profit, and for-profit organizations across critical business factors:

Switching organizational types

Organizations sometimes need to change their structure. For example, a nonprofit might want to start a for-profit business to attract investors, or a for-profit might want to become a nonprofit to pursue a social mission. It’s a challenging process, but conversion between structures is possible.

Converting from nonprofit or not-for-profit to for-profit

It’s not possible to convert a 501(c)(3) nonprofit directly into a for-profit business, but you do have two options that will get you there in a roundabout way. Which route you take largely depends on your reasons for making the change. 

• Do you want to sell products, services, or programs that are outside of the scope of what the IRS allows nonprofits to sell? Instead of terminating your nonprofit, you may want to establish a separate for-profit business for those purposes. In this case, you’d be able to continue the work of furthering your nonprofit’s mission, while simultaneously running a separate for-profit business that complements that mission. If you go this route, it’s crucial you operate your nonprofit and for-profit entities independently from each other to avoid violating IRS rules regarding conflicts of interest. 
• Your other option is to dissolve your nonprofit and restart your mission as a for-profit business. The nonprofit dissolution process involves a number of steps, including the redistribution of your assets to another 501(c)(3) organization. It is not possible to transfer nonprofit assets to a for-profit business. Before registering as a for-profit business, you’ll also need to notify the IRS of the dissolution of your nonprofit. 

Converting from for-profit to nonprofit

Converting to nonprofit status also involves complexity. The IRS intentionally makes this process rigorous to prevent tax avoidance schemes.

The for-profit to nonprofit conversion process requires the following:

• A mission statement detailing how you’ll serve society as a nonprofit, including specific charitable purposes.
• Written bylaws adopted through board vote. You can adapt existing corporate bylaws or create new ones, and either retain current board members or appoint new ones.
• Articles of incorporation filed with your state’s secretary of state office.
• Compliance with state-specific conversion rules. For instance, New York requires creating a separate nonprofit, then merging it with your for-profit venture.

Which business structure should you choose?

Your ideal structure depends entirely on your goals, values, and vision. The good news? You can start any of these business types with minimal capital.

If making a positive impact through education, charity, or social causes drives you, consider a nonprofit. You’ll serve the public good and receive tax benefits as you work to support your mission. Keep in mind that you’ll also have to navigate strict rules about profit usage and personal compensation.

For those wanting to benefit a specific group or community without nonprofit restrictions, a not-for-profit offers some more flexibility. Profits stay within the organization, but you’ll have more operational freedom than a nonprofit.

If generating income is your goal—whether through an online store or another venture—a for-profit business makes sense. You’ll have maximum flexibility with finances and compensation, while also having full tax obligations on your profits.

Decision flowchart: Which structure fits your goals?

To help you choose the right organizational structure, consider these key questions:

1. What’s your primary goal?

• Advancing a social cause or public benefit → Consider nonprofit
• Serving a specific group or membership → Consider not-for-profit
• Generating income and building wealth → Choose for-profit

2. How important are tax benefits?

• Need donor tax deductions for fundraising → Nonprofit 501(c)(3)
• Want organizational tax exemption only → Not-for-profit may work
• Tax benefits not critical → For-profit offers other advantages

3. Who controls decision-making?

• Board of directors serving public interest → Nonprofit structure
• Members or a specific group → Not-for-profit structure
• Owners/shareholders → For-profit structure

4. What happens to excess revenue?

• Must reinvest in mission → Nonprofit or not-for-profit
• Want to distribute to owners → For-profit only

After selecting your structure, it’s time to register your business, obtain required business licenses, choose your business name, and develop your business strategy. Understanding the different types of nonprofits, types of businesses, and business models available can help you make the most informed decision for your venture.